Facebook
Instagram
Free Local Delivery!
Petsense
New Arrivals
Dog
Dog Food
Dry Dog Food
Wet Dog Food
Freeze Dried Dog Food
Top Brands
4health
Acana
Blue Buffalo
Diamond
Fromm
Merrick
Orijen
Pro Plan
Royal Canin
Science Diet
Taste of the Wild
Dog Treats & Accessories
Treats & Chews
Toys
Beds & Mats
Bowls & Feeders
Cleaning & Potty
Clothing & Accessories
Flea & Tick
Grooming Supplies
Health & Supplements
Leashes, Collars & Harnesses
Cat
Cat Food
Dry Cat Food
Wet Cat Food
Freeze Dried Cat Food
Top Brands
4health
Acana
Blue Buffalo
Fancy Feast
Friskies
Fromm
Iams
Merrick
Orijen
Pro Plan
Royal Canin
Science Diet
Tidy Cats
Cat Treats & Accessories
Treats
Toys
Litter
Litter Boxes & Supplies
Beds & Hideaways
Bowls & Feeders
Flea & Tick
Furniture & Scratchers
Grooming
Health & Supplements
Small Pet
Small Pets
Pet Bird
Pet Fish
Reptile
Small Animal
Top Brands
A&E Cage Company
API
Fluker Farms
Higgins Premium Pet Foods
Lee's Aquarium and Pets
Oxbow Animal Health
Prevue Pet
Vitakraft
Zoo Med Laboratories
Zupreem
Petsense Picks
Services
Services
Grooming
Wag! Pet Services
Pet Insurance
Subscription
Prescription
Adoption
Training
Vet Clinics
Find A Store
New Arrivals
Petsense Picks
Dogs
Dog Food
Dry Food
Wet Food
Freeze Dried
Treats & Chews
Toys
Beds & Mats
Bowls & Feeders
Cleaning & Potty
Clothing & Accessories
Collars, Leashes & Training
Flea & Tick
Grooming Supplies
Health & Supplements
Cats
Cat Food
Dry Food
Wet Food
Freeze Dried
Treats
Toys
Litter
Litter Boxes & Supplies
Beds & Hideaways
Bowls & Feeders
Flea & Tick
Furniture & Scratchers
Grooming
Health & Supplements
Small Pet
Small Animal
Pet Bird
Pet Fish
Reptile
Grooming & Services
Grooming
Wag! Pet Services
Pet Insurance
Adoption
Training
Vet Clinics
Subscription
Prescription
Neighbor's Club
Find A Store
Login
Email Address
Password
Forgot password?
Register for account
Search
Search
Cart
Plush Toys
Pet
Dog
Cat
Availability
pickup in store
ship to me
delivery
Brand
Ethical Pet
Go Dog
KONG
MultiPet
Outward Hound
Lifestage
Adult
All Stages
Breed Size
All Breeds
Large
Medium
Small
Filter
Toys
Showing 49 - 96 of 115 products
Sort By
Featured
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
A-Z
Z-A
Oldest to Newest
Newest to Oldest
Best Selling
KONG Comfort Kiddos Elephant Plush Dog Toy
$5.99
Mad Cat Oh So Jolly 3pk Holiday Cat Toy
$4.99
Sale
Outward Hound Durablez Squirrel/Raccoon 2/PK Dog Toys XS
$12.99
Outward Hound Tough Skinz Watermelon Dog Toy Red Med
$7.99
Charming Pet Scrunch Bunch Duck Dog Toy
$11.99
Patchwork Pet Pastel Octopus Dog Toy
$5.99
Sale
KONG Refillables Squirrel Cat Toy
$9.99
KONG Sherps™ Donkey Medium Dog Toy
$14.99
KONG Cat Active Wild Tails Assorted Cat Toy
$8.99
KONG Refillables Feather Mouse Cat Toy
$8.99
ZippyPaws Zippy Burrow Dog Toy, Arctic Wolf
$33.99
ZippyPaws Squeakie Can Dog Toy, Le Chien
$8.99
goDog Fuzzy Wuzzy Lamb Squeaky Plush Dog Toy, Chew Guard Technology, Small
$9.99
Ethical Products SPOT Skinneeez Extreme Octopus Assorted 16"
$9.99
Ethical Products SPOT Skinneeez Mallard Duck 14.5"
$11.99
Ethical Products SPOT Plush Soccer Ball 4.5"
$4.59
Ethical Products SPOT Skinneeez Crinkler Cow 23"
$11.19
ZippyPaws Squeakie Emojiz Pizza Slice Plush Dog Toy
$9.99
Snugarooz Marty the Moose Plush Dog Toy
$9.99
Snugarooz Saul the Shark Plush Dog Toy
$15.99
ZippyPaws Zippy Burrow Hedgehog Den Hide & Seek Puzzle Dog Toy
$17.99
Snugarooz Sally the Stingray Plush Dog Toy
$23.99
Snugarooz Sasha the Sloth Plush Dog Toy
$18.99
KONG Duckie Refillable Catnip Plush Toy
$7.99
KONG Plush Beaver Dog Toy
$7.99
Mad Cat Elfin Around Wand Holiday Cat Toy
$4.99
Sale
Mad Cat Santa Paws Milk 2pk Holiday Cat Toy
$4.99
Sale
Outward Hound Fire Biterz Gnome/Mushroom 2/PK Dog Toys SM
$14.99
Outward Hound Durablez Owl/Fox 2/PK Dog Toys XS
$12.99
Outward Hound Stuffing Free Fox Dog Toy Orange Med
$14.99
Outward Hound Firehose Fecth Zebra Dog Toy Green Large
$19.99
Outward Hound Fire Biterz Giraffe Dog Toy Med
$9.99
Outward Hound Durablez Gecko Dog Toy Orange Med
$7.99
Outward Hound Ranch Roperz Chicken Dog Toy Yellow Small
$11.99
goDog Just For Me Gators Squeaky Plush Dog Toy, Chew Guard Technology, Pink, Mini
$5.99
Patchwork Pet Ellie Elephant Dog Toy
$14.24
Sale
Patchwork Pet PatchCat Theatre Box Cat Toy
$11.24
Sale
Patchwork Pet PatchCat Space Box Cat Toy
$11.24
Sale
Patchwork Pet PatchCat Party Box Cat Toy
$11.24
Sale
Patchwork Pet PatchCat Fruit Set Cat Toy
$4.49
Sale
Patchwork Pet PatchCat Bath Time Set Cat Toy
$4.49
Sale
KONG Refillables Carrot w/Feather Top Cat Toy
$8.99
KONG Wubba™ Camo Assorted XL Dog Toy
$21.99
KONG Sherps™ Floofs Big Horn Medium Dog Toy
$15.99
KONG Better Buzz™ Banana Assorted Cat Toy
$8.99
KONG Naturals® Crinkle Fish 2pk Assorted Cat Toy
$8.99
View Product Details